Solution Matrix • Cost-Benefit-Analysis

Lease / FASB-13

Encyclopedia of Business Terms and Methods, ISBN 978-1-929500-10-9. Copyright © 2011 by Marty J.Schmidt.

The Meaning of Lease, Operating Lease, Capital Lease, and FASB-13

A lease contract is an agreement under which the original owner of property permits someone else to use it. The original owner is the lessor and the user of the property is the lessee. There are many kinds of leases and subtleties to lease contracts, but the major distinction to be aware of is the difference between operating leases and capital leases.

Operating vs. Capital Leases 
FASB-13 ruling on Operating vs. Capital Leases

Operating vs. Capital Leases

An operating lease contract is similar to a rental contract: The lessee pays fees for the life of the lease and simply uses the goods (e.g., a computer system). The lessee reports these costs as operating expenses (and thus lowers taxes in this way), but takes no depreciation expense. The lessor (owner), however, can claim depreciation expenses and take tax benefits. When the lease is over, the lessee surrenders the property (or renews the lease, or perhaps has an option then to purchase outright). Operating leases differ from rental contracts, primarily in that leases are more binding (have bigger penalties for early canceling), and usually cover longer terms. An operating lease generally covers a time period significantly less than the expected life of the leased goods.

Capital leases are more like financed purchases, that is, under the terms of the lease, the lessee may immediately gain some of the benefits of ownership, such as charging depreciation expense (and taking tax benefits from that), and recognize the asset on the balance sheet as a capital asset. In the United States, the distinction capital and operating leases is based on the Financial Accounting Standards Board, Statement 13.

[ Page Top ]     [ Encyclopedia ]     [ Business Case Books & Tools ]     [ Home ]

FASB 13 Ruling on Operating vs. Capital Leases

The United States Financial Accounting Standards Board statement 13 (FASB 13) provides the definitions and criteria for deciding whether or not a lease agreement is to be considered a purchase/sale agreement (and therefore a capital lease) or a usage agreement (and therefore an operating lease). The distinction between capital and operating leases has important financial consequences: it determines who (lessor or lessee) has ownership rights and who takes depreciation for the leased goods, who can treat lease costs as expenses, and other factors.

For proper explanation of FASB 13 criteria and usage, consult a leasing guide or financial textbook. Very briefly, FASB 13 states that a lease will be considered an operating lease (usage agreement) unless one or more of the following four criteria are met. If any of the following applies, the lease is then treated as a capital lease (purchase/sale agreement):

  • The lease automatically transfers ownership of the property to the lessee by the end of the lease.
  • The lease contains a bargain purchase option.
  • The lease term equals 75% or more of the estimated economic life of the property.
  • The present value of the minimum lease payments at the beginning of the lease term equals or exceeds 90% of the fair market value of the property.

[ Page Top ]     [ Encyclopedia ]     [ Business Case Books & Tools ]     [ Home ]

Pacioli ]

The Best Selling Authority on Business Case Analysis

Business Case Essentials, 3rd Ed

The concise, complete guide to what belongs in a business case and why. The trusted authority on business case analysis assumes no prior background in finance or business planning. Essentials provides clear, practical, step-by-step guidance for building a compelling business case. Essentials covers

  • Financial metrics including Retun on investment (ROI), NPV, and total cost of ownership (TCO).
  • Other important financial and non-financial outcomes.
  • Real world examples from industry, government, and non profit settings.

BookReview.com says: Excellent!
"Business Case Essentials is exactly what it says it is, one of the few practical references on business cases available ... should be stocked on the shelves of every company looking to maintain a critical advantage in these shifting waters of economic growth and recovery."
Eric Jones, BookReview.com (Read the review).

Read an overiew and order the Essentials printed edition online. Or, download the e-book today.

Business Case
Professional Seminars

Learn case building at the premier business case seminar

Two days hands on learning and practice with the leading source for business case training. Join more than 16,000 professionals on five continents who successfully completed Building the Business Case seminars. Qualify for professional education credits!

Register online and download business case books and tools immediately.
Request detailed seminar contents and agendas.

Business Case Guide

The Recognized Standard

Business Case Guide The practical in-depth Guide to successful cost benefit analysis and business case presentation. Download the recognized standard source.

Business Case Sites

Solution Matrix Ltd

Solution Matrix Germany

Solution Matrix Asia

Solution Matrix Pacific

Business Case Newsletter

Read newsletter past issues

  • ROI Users Survival Guide
  • Getting a Yes from the CFO
  • Business Case Critics:
    De-Clawing the Cat
  • Do "Soft" Benefits Belong in a Business Case?
  • And more...

Subscribe to the free weekly newsletter and receive a free
e-mail course: "5 Days to Success with Your Business Case"



We value your privacy
Read newsletter past issues